Warning- This Show Contains Outdated Cultural Depictions
Ferchrisakes, this was G-rated, every family in America loved Bonanza; Hoss, Little Joe and the gang whupping bad guys while they dealt with all the intricacies and difficulties of the late 19th century West on or near the Nevada/California line. Now, almost sixty years after the original shows aired, we might be offended by one of the least offensive and squeaky clean shows to ever grace the air waves.
I was fascinated by what could be the "Outdated Cultural Depictions" someone somewhere in the offices of Get TV felt deserved mentioning. I watched most of that episode, you know the one with the two nuns in a stage coach along with Hoss. They get robbed of all the money they had scrimped and saved to build a hospital for the needy in Denver.
While I watched this Horse Opera unfold, I failed to see any depiction that might offend anyone. The story was a gag reflex inducing tale of sacrifice for Lord, our God in Heaven that left one nun dead while the other regains her hospital money and a bright light breaks through the Ponderosa pines as someone rides off into the sunset.
I mentioned this to my wife who claimed she did not watch Bonanza as a child. Yet she was able to point out the obvious 'Outdated Cultural Depiction". Two words passed her lips.
"Hop Sing"Immediately it dawned on me. The reason I did not think of Hop Sing was he was not in that episode. And almost as immediate, I realized as insanely unforgiving as the Cancel Culture was over the Past not spoiling our Present or our Future; it almost equals the zeal with which the White Wing Peckerwoods use to try to return that Past and force it into our Present. Between the two of them, we just cannot catch a break.
Yes, Hop Sing played a servant in the series. But, Bonanza was known for their, at the time, groundbreaking sensitive character portrayals that attempted to not denigrate, but to integrate. Native Americans were always treated with the best intentions of that period. The only nasty people on the show were all the bad white guys the gang at the Ponderosa tangled with on a weekly basis.
I know that the shows of my youth would not stand the scrutiny and criticisms of 2022 television. But warning people they may be offended is bush league stupidity. If the Past offends someone in the future, they need to get a grip and move on.
And folks don't understand why I am almost as pissed off with the Left now as I am with the Right.
Keep it 'tween the ditches ...........................................
________________________________________
There is only one tune I can think of for this post. Lorne Green singing the theme to Bonanza. Enjoy!
4 comments:
I'm with you on the Ultra Left and the Ultra Right (there is no other Right at the moment) are both batshit crazy. And prone to anti-science conspiracy theories or crazy ideologies. There is even some overlap. The anti-Imperialists (Bill Blum, Noam Chomsky) and Isolationists (MTG) are opposed to American Imperialism but OK with Russian or Chinese.
Their arguments against the beef industry and Roundup/Neonics are as bad as the Arguments against Climate Change or vaccines.
When you look at some of the shit proposed by Dems in Colorado, as I have said many times, if I were a commercial farmer or rancher in America, I would be forced to hold my nose and vote Republican just to save my business. In the same way that progressive Dems need to hold their noses and vote even for moderate (corporate Dems) just to save democracy.
In the 80s when I first went to Tahoe, which is where the ranch was, I discovered "cultural depiction". In the show they would get on a horse or wagon and a little while later would be in Virginia City. I drove from Tahoe to Virginia City in a car, granted it was an Escort, but it took a couple hours. Also Virginia City is not flat like the back lot where they shot the show. It is built on a hillside.
Blog Fodder: "if I were a commercial farmer or rancher in America, I would be forced to hold my nose and vote Republican just to save my business."
That's the problem in this country, too many business people think they have to support the GOP, when in reality the country does much better financially when the Dems are in control!
Oh... I know version about such town on the border of Canada and USA.
Lovely one.
I bet Hop Sing peed in their soup.
Post a Comment